gage R&Rgage study

Why calibration does NOT ensure you will have accurate measurements

If this headline is surprising to you, let me explain how Six Sigma taught me this important concept, and why Gage R&R is one of my favorite analysis techniques.

In school I studied Statistics and Quality Management and Productivity, but I didn’t learn much about Gage R&R studies.

It was my mentors from the Automotive industry that educated me (thank you to Tim and Mel!)

So I started conducting these measurement experiments at the aerospace company I worked at, and I was asking people to remeasure each part more than once, and asking others to measure the same parts.

The results were shocking!

More often than not, the way the data was collected was adding significant variation into the process and increasing the chance of false failures or false passes.

Yikes!

It happened with CMMs, blood testing laboratories, high-tech test equipment, chemical meters, calipers, pull test machines, leak testers, micrometers, and more.

My favorite example was when the test results changed when I tested the product in another building (it was better protected from airport signal noise).

The problem is most people don’t understand how the people and process impact the measurements.

They falsely assume that calibration is all you need.

Calibration is critical to good measurements, but it only addresses the bias or accuracy concerns, not the variation or precision.

Precision is evaluated by taking repeat measurements and having other people or equipment repeat the measurements on the same items (reproducibility). That’s why it’s called Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (R&R).

Ideally all the results come out the same no matter who measures the items.

If not, we have measurement variation that is not related to calibration.

I’ve had multiple projects get resolved just by fixing the measurement variation. The process variation goes away and the yields improve. I didn’t have to go any further on the project, as we were already seeing cost savings.

If you’re interested in learning more about Gage R&R studies, check out our online self-paced Green Belt course, or more advanced versions in our Black Belt course (coming soon in late 2026!) or consider taking our Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA) online course